YMMV. It obviously does. But *this* is how I feel about much of BtVS season 6. Is the author a redemptionista? Yeah. But her review tackles what went wrong with the plotting, characterization, anvilisciousness, and story-arcs, with what seem to me to be very sound, critical, non-redemption-driven arguments. They certainly describe how I've been feeling about Buffy all season.
Thanks to firehorse for the link.